Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices in the USA - September 2026

Andy’s Frozen Custard menu items run from simple cones to loaded Jackhammers. This guide lists every current price. Nothing here is estimated.

Andy’s started in 1986 in Osage Beach, Missouri. John and Carol Kuntz opened the first shop after tasting frozen custard in Wisconsin. Their son Andy later expanded the business to Springfield.

Springfield became the company’s true home base. The Kuntz family still runs Andy’s today. The chain has since grown into the largest frozen custard-only company in the country.

Andy’s now operates 192 restaurants. These locations are spread across 15 states. Most stores still cluster around the Midwest and the South.

Happy Hour Deals

Andy’s runs a recurring loyalty deal instead of a daily happy hour window. Free Tea Tuesdays gives loyalty members a free 24oz iced tea with any $5 purchase, every Tuesday. New loyalty members also get a free small one-topping concrete on signup, and a free treat on their birthday month.

Interactive Page Extras

• Suggested Meal Budget: $5 to $7 per person, one treat and a drink.
• Upsell Item Name: Pick 6 (six half pints, mix and match flavors)
• Upsell Item Price: $16.99
• Secret Menu Hacks: The PB&J Jackhammer, a peanut butter and jelly custard blend, has circulated as a build-it-yourself off-menu order at some locations, confirmed through an official Andy’s social video.

Locations, Cuisines, Amenities

• Locations: 192 restaurants across 15 U.S. states, with the highest concentration in Missouri, Arkansas, Texas, and Oklahoma.
• Cuisines: Frozen custard, ice cream desserts, shakes, malts
• Amenities: Drive-thru at most locations, walk-up window, dine-in patio seating at some stores, loyalty app ordering, Andy’s Anywhere take-home program

Timings and Hours

Store hours vary slightly by location, but most Andy’s restaurants follow a similar weekly pattern. Weeknights close earlier than weekends, since custard is always made fresh in small hourly batches.

Some locations close slightly earlier, around 11:00 PM on weeknights. Always check your specific store before a late visit, especially around holidays.

The Full Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu

Prices below are listed in US dollars. Most items can be made with either vanilla or chocolate custard.

Does Delivery Cost More at Andy’s Frozen Custard

Not always. A price check across several delivery listings found matching prices in most cases. A Triple Chocolate Concrete ran $5.09 both in store and on a sampled Uber Eats listing.

This is unusual compared to some other chains. Andy’s appears to keep delivery pricing closer to its in-store menu. Small differences may still appear by location.

Must-Try Dishes at Andy’s Frozen Custard

A few treats show up again and again in reviews.

• James Brown Funky Jackhammer, $6.29. A rich, chocolate-forward Jackhammer that regulars order by name.
• The Original Straw-ana Sundae, $4.94. Reviewers often add hot fudge for extra richness.
• Andy’s Ozark Turtle Sundae, $5.69. A caramel and pecan favorite tied to the brand’s Ozarks roots.
• Bootdaddy Concrete, $5.39. Blends Oreo cookies with creme caramel and hot fudge.

How Much Does Andy’s Frozen Custard Cost

Andy’s sits in the budget treat range for dessert chains. Small cones and shakes start around $2 to $4. Concretes and Jackhammers run $5 to $7.

For one person, a treat and a drink typically runs $6 to $9. Two people sharing a Pick 6 and a Quart Combo land around $30 to $31.

Alternative Restaurants in Springfield, Missouri

Andy’s is a Springfield staple, but the city has other strong dessert spots worth trying. These local shops cover ice cream, gelato, and non-dairy frozen treats.

These local shops give a break from chain dessert options. Menus and hours change often at smaller shops. Confirm current details before visiting any of them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Word

Andy’s Frozen Custard menu covers everything from a $2.35 apple slice side to a $16.99 Pick 6. Whether you want a quick cone or a full Jackhammer, the tables above show what to expect before you order.